|
We
know the ColorSpan DisplayMaker XII and Mach 12 function because
we use both daily
 |
|
Colorspan
Displaymaker at FLAAR BGSU
|
FLAAR has one XII and one Mach 12. Both produce signs, posters,
banners, and fine art giclee prints every day here at the
university. We have the DisplayMaker XII with 8 colors (CMYK,
light magenta, medium magenta, light cyan, medium magenta)
and hope to add the four quad black B+W for fine art and museum
quality photos shortly.
The
Mach 12 has eight colors and we hope to upgrade it to full
12 colors this month.
The
ColorSpan Mach 12 was exhibited two years ago and is gradually
maturing. If you select triple CMYK mode you get all the speed
of the Hewlett-Packard wide-path printheads plus three sets
of parallel paths. These are the same HP printheads in the
Hewlett-Packard DesignJet 5000 and 5500. Thus you get the
expected quality of a thermal printhead design. But if you
use 8 inks you get wider color gamut. If you employ all 12
inks you get still more color gamut.
The
Epson printers can handle media up to 1.5 mm thick. The ColorSpan
DisplayMaker Mach 12 can handle media up to 3.175 mm thick,
so over twice as thick as any Epson printer.
Color
management is on board. For most other printers you have to
print a color swatch and then feed it manually into an X-Rite
or GretagMacbeth color measuring tool. These cost between
$2,000 and up to stratospheric prices. The ColorSpan has an
auto-read magic eye camera built in. Can read linearization
and color management profiles on normal media. Since transparent
media is obviously transparent, that you need to either have
backed or else do a manual test for backlit media.
This
means you can create your own ICC
color profiles in the comfort of your own office. Which
means that for every media and ink combination you now have
the International Color Consortium color profiles.
You
can print on 24" media, 36" media, 42" or 54"
or 60" or up to 72" media. Since MacDermid-ColorSpan
also owns Kilborn photographic media company you can expect
a good combination of ink and media. Every ink works best
only with certain media. Some media works better with specific
inks and not as well with another ink. So if you get the
ink
and media from the same company then the combination is widely
documented to produce results superior to you merely using
some miscellaneous media.
With
my early model Encad,
which lacks a dryer, I can appreciate the sophisticated dryer
which is part of a ColorSpan DisplayMaker.
Anyone
who owns a lesser printer will want the tilt-up printhead
carriage now available on the Mach 12. This means you can
clean the ink cartridges without pulling them out individually.
The new model also has hot-swap ink change capability. It's
clear that the new MacDermid owners of ColorSpan are working
hard to improve over the earlier corporate owners (VirtualFund).
The combination of new owners, new policies of improved tech
support, and the new model all combine to make ColorSpan a
printer that any sign shop, photo lab, or fine art giclee
studio should seriously consider.
Improvements
on the Mach 12
When
the Mach 12 first came out years ago it had serious banding
defects. Thus we did not obtain this model in those years.
Since then the printer has been fine-tuned and redesigned.
When we felt the printer was ready, then we asked for one
to evaluate. It arrived this summer. So far I have seen continued
museum-quality output from the Mach 12 which is in the FLAAR
lab a few feet from my office on the campus of Bowling Green
State University. The Mach 12 works great and produces output
you can sell to happy clients.
What
most impressed me about the Mach 12 was the lack of grainy
dot pattern which characterized the DisplayMaker XII and HP
DesignJet 2000 and 3000 series. Of course if you are printing
signs or tradeshow displays you don't see the grainy dots
from a distance. But I want photo-realistic quality. This
means I do not accept excessive dot pattern nor horizontal
banding.
Actually
one of the first people to come to our lab and ask for test
prints was a person from the art department. They have other
brands of printers there, but he walked a mile over to our
building across campus because the Mach 12 and HP 5000ps are
easier to use (and much more economical in ink and media)
than the antiquated piezo printer in the art building. We
use dye inks in the Mach 12 and pigmented inks in the HP.
For most normal usage people prefer 8 colors dye in the Mach
12 because of its impressive color gamut.
Circa 2002 FLAAR moved directly adjacent to the art department,
so we are already besieged by art students and faculty.
The
Mach 12 is still fairly new, but gradually we are issuing
reports and updating our web pages . We
are also updating our tradeshow reports (SGIA '02) with info
on the newer model of ColorSpan, the X12.
In subsequent years water-based printers began to be replaced with eco-solvent chemistry. This in turn is now replaced in part by UV-curable inkjet chemistry. ColorSpan makes popular entry-level UV-cured flatbed printers. You can obtain material directly by asking UV_flatbeds@ColorSpan.com.
If
you are a sign shop, product comparisons include Roland, ColorSpan,
Hewlett-Packard, Encad, Graphtec, etc: "FLAAR report
on wide format inkjet printers for sign shops"
If
you are a photo studio or individual photographer, what you
want is the "FLAAR comparative report for photo-realistic
inkjet printers."
If
you are an artist or fine art giclee studio, what will assist
you most is the "FLAAR comparative report on inkjet printers
for fine art giclee."
"RIPs
+ Help." A friendly report that helps first-time users
recognize what they need to get started in the world of large
format inkjet printing software.
Assistance
on learning about inkjet media, tips and help are always useful.
Check out the FLAAR Report-SERIES on wide format canvas, vinyl,
photo base, watercolor paper, and other inkjet media.
Most of these earlier reports are available now.
|
Informative
FLAAR reports,
on
large format printers at CeBIT and simultaneously
at ISA trade shows
|
| Best
improvement of new model over previous model |
shows
which earlier models were "worst in show"
last year but the replacement models presented at CeBIT
and ISA trade shows 2001 were dramatically improved. |
| Most
potential for a new model |
which
new inkjet printer prototype(s) may well develop into
a future "Best in Show" |
| Most
popular inkjet printer at show |
Which
large format printer was used in the booths of the greatest
quantity of other digital imaging companies? Which inkjet
printer got the most favorable comments from visitors
and from other digital imaging professionals? |
| Highest
Quality of any Solvent Ink printer |
Thermal
printhead technology has many pros and a few cons.
Epson piezo-electric printhead technology has one
positive feature and several downsides. Solvent-ink
piezo printhead technology has two positive aspects
and several negative aspects.
This
we nominate a "best of class" for each technology.
Due to so few printers of Herz, electrostatic or UV
curable technology and so few of dye diffusion (dye
sub resin and wax colorants), these printers are not
in the "best of..." award system (but are
definitely included in our FLAAR thematic reports).
|
| Highest
Quality of any thermal printhead printer |
| Highest
Quality of any piezo printer |
| Most
unimpressive printer(s) at the show. |
Since
the XES Xpress is phased out and as no Fuji-Hunt "Brady"
printer was visible, there is no longer a "worst
in show" award, but there were definitely several
inkjet printers that simply don't match up to the
better models of their competition.
These
are potentially the printers you may wish to avoid,
so this
trade show report is an invaluable aid to
any individual or company which is about to decide
what printer to buy.
|
|
Covers
Accuplot, Agfa, ANAgraph, Canon, ColorSpan, ColorWings,
Encad, Epson, Gretag, Hewlett-Packard, Ilford, Konica,
Matan Sprinter, Mimaki, Mutah, Nur, Oce, Roland, ScitexVision,
Seiko, Stork, Vutek, XES (Xerox).
FLAAR
Reports are in Adobe Acrobat (PDF) format so download
easily and quickly. They open as an attractive report.
Our
university is pleased to make these reports available
to you as part of our sponsored program of public
education.
|
|
|
|
|
All reports by Dr. Nicholas Hellmuth |
Most recently updated July 31, 2007. Previously updated :
Feb. 06/2002, Updated August 1, 2002; last updated Nov.
12, 2002
|